ICML 2022

Structural Entropy Guided Graph Hierarchical Pooling

Junran Wu, Xueyuan Chen, Ke Xu, Shangzhe Li

Main figure for Structural Entropy Guided Graph Hierarchical Pooling

Abstract

Following the success of convolution on non-Euclidean space, the corresponding pooling approaches have also been validated on various tasks regarding graphs. However, because of the fixed compression quota and stepwise pooling design, these hierarchical pooling methods still suffer from local structure damage and suboptimal problem. In this work, inspired by structural entropy, we propose a hierarchical pooling approach, SEP, to tackle the two issues. Specifically, without assigning the layer-specific compression quota, a global optimization algorithm is designed to generate the cluster assignment matrices for pooling at once. Then, we present an illustration of the local structure damage from previous methods in the reconstruction of ring and grid synthetic graphs. In addition to SEP, we further design two classification models, SEP-G and SEP-N for graph classification and node classification, respectively. The results show that SEP outperforms state-of-the-art graph pooling methods on graph classification benchmarks and obtains superior performance on node classifications.

Proposed method: SEP-G

Benchmark Results

Tested on 10 datasets 42 baseline values reported too low

Tables show presented results in global context (best 3 papers + GCN + MLP).

Classic

#ModelAccuracy ↑Paper
1
GraphSAGE+CNA
0.9418 ±0.0033
2
GCN+CNA
0.9366 ±0.0048
3
TransformerConv
0.9350 ±0.0058
21
GCN
actual #21 vs paper #578 557 places worse
0.9004
best reported
actual #21 vs paper #578 557 places worse
paper 0.8140 ±0.0040
paper 0.8140 ±0.0040 Δ at pub 0.0577 Δ today 0.0864
39
SAGE
0.8911 ±0.0012
44
GAT
actual #44 vs paper #389 345 places worse
0.8897 ±0.0014
best reported
actual #44 vs paper #389 345 places worse
paper 0.8330 ±0.0070
paper 0.8330 ±0.0070 Δ at pub 0.0560 Δ today 0.0567
45
GCNII
actual #45 vs paper #203 158 places worse
0.8893 ±0.0137
best reported
actual #45 vs paper #203 158 places worse
paper 0.8550 ±0.0050
best at pub: Orthogonal Graph Neural Networks (AAAI 2021)
paper 0.8550 ±0.0050 Δ at pub 0.0299 Δ today 0.0343
108
APPNP
actual #108 vs paper #389 281 places worse
0.8787
best reported
actual #108 vs paper #389 281 places worse
paper 0.8330 ±0.0050
best at pub: Orthogonal Graph Neural Networks (AAAI 2021)
paper 0.8330 ±0.0050 Δ at pub 0.0457 Δ today 0.0457
113
MixHop
actual #113 vs paper #550 437 places worse
0.8761 ±0.0203
best reported
actual #113 vs paper #550 437 places worse
paper 0.8180 ±0.0060
165
GIN
actual #165 vs paper #725 560 places worse
0.8660 ±0.0091
best reported
actual #165 vs paper #725 560 places worse
paper 0.7760 ±0.0110
paper 0.7760 ±0.0110 Δ at pub 0.0420 Δ today 0.0900
177
DGI
actual #177 vs paper #465 288 places worse
0.8630 ±0.0020
best reported
actual #177 vs paper #465 288 places worse
paper 0.8250 ±0.0070
223
SGC
actual #223 vs paper #606 383 places worse
0.8509 ±0.0648
best reported
actual #223 vs paper #606 383 places worse
paper 0.8100 ±0.0003
226
FastGCN
actual #226 vs paper #666 440 places worse
0.8500
best reported
actual #226 vs paper #666 440 places worse
paper 0.7980 ±0.0030
paper 0.7980 ±0.0030 Δ at pub 0.0520 Δ today 0.0520
234
SEP-N
0.8480 ±0.0040
This paper
261
g-U-Nets
0.8440 ±0.0060
This paper
366
S^2GC
actual #366 vs paper #366
0.8350 ±0.0002
actual #366 vs paper #366
paper 0.8350 ±0.0002
paper 0.8350 ±0.0002 Δ at pub 0.0080
724
MLP
0.7768
#ModelAccuracy ↑Paper
1
CNA
0.9575 ±0.0058
2
IS-GIB
0.9390 ±0.0187
3
EERM
0.9112 ±0.0145
20
APPNP
actual #20 vs paper #481 461 places worse
0.8142 ±0.0026
best reported
actual #20 vs paper #481 461 places worse
paper 0.7170 ±0.0060
paper 0.7170 ±0.0060 Δ at pub 0.0880 Δ today 0.0972
35
GAT
actual #35 vs paper #373 338 places worse
0.8080 ±0.0026
best reported
actual #35 vs paper #373 338 places worse
paper 0.7260 ±0.0060
paper 0.7260 ±0.0060 Δ at pub 0.0753 Δ today 0.0820
44
GCN
actual #44 vs paper #561 517 places worse
0.8033 ±0.0088
best reported
actual #44 vs paper #561 517 places worse
paper 0.7090 ±0.0050
paper 0.7090 ±0.0050 Δ at pub 0.0853 Δ today 0.0943
61
GraphSAGE
0.7923 ±0.0053
66
DGI
actual #66 vs paper #496 430 places worse
0.7890 ±0.0020
best reported
actual #66 vs paper #496 430 places worse
paper 0.7160 ±0.0070
97
FastGCN
actual #97 vs paper #658 561 places worse
0.7765 ±0.0005
best reported
actual #97 vs paper #658 561 places worse
paper 0.6880 ±0.0060
96
SGC
actual #96 vs paper #463 367 places worse
0.7765 ±0.0012
best reported
actual #96 vs paper #463 367 places worse
paper 0.7190 ±0.0011
126
MixHop
actual #126 vs paper #519 393 places worse
0.7140 ±0.0080
actual #126 vs paper #519 393 places worse
paper 0.7140 ±0.0080
prev best: Contrastive Laplacian Eigenmaps (NeurIPS 2022)
paper 0.7140 ±0.0080 Δ at pub 0.0430 Δ today 0.0486
264
S^2GC
actual #264 vs paper #264
0.7360 ±0.0009
actual #264 vs paper #264
paper 0.7360 ±0.0009
paper 0.7360 ±0.0009 Δ at pub 0.0060
306
g-U-Nets
0.7320 ±0.0050
This paper
346
SEP-N
0.7290 ±0.0070
This paper
350
MLP
0.7289 ±0.0010
389
GIN
actual #389 vs paper #751 362 places worse
0.7250 ±0.0080
best reported
actual #389 vs paper #751 362 places worse
paper 0.6610 ±0.0090
paper 0.6610 ±0.0090 Δ at pub 0.0640
#ModelAccuracy ↑Paper
1
LGTL
0.9518 ±0.0011
2
MixHop (LO)
0.9513 ±0.0038
3
GraphSAGE (LO)
0.9511 ±0.0036
18
GCN
actual #18 vs paper #585 567 places worse
0.9296 ±0.0015
best reported
actual #18 vs paper #585 567 places worse
paper 0.7900 ±0.0040
70
MixHop
actual #70 vs paper #447 377 places worse
0.9004 ±0.0141
best reported
actual #70 vs paper #447 377 places worse
paper 0.8000 ±0.0110
paper 0.8000 ±0.0110 Δ at pub 0.0080 Δ today 0.1004
116
SAGE
0.8881 ±0.0015
141
SGC
actual #141 vs paper #602 461 places worse
0.8832 ±0.0055
best reported
actual #141 vs paper #602 461 places worse
paper 0.7890 ±0.0001
157
GIN
actual #157 vs paper #739 582 places worse
0.8810
best reported
actual #157 vs paper #739 582 places worse
paper 0.7700 ±0.0120
paper 0.7700 ±0.0120 Δ at pub 0.0376 Δ today 0.1110
159
FastGCN
actual #159 vs paper #716 557 places worse
0.8800
best reported
actual #159 vs paper #716 557 places worse
paper 0.7740 ±0.0030
paper 0.7740 ±0.0030 Δ at pub 0.1060 Δ today 0.1060
204
DGI
actual #204 vs paper #646 442 places worse
0.8708 ±0.0017
best reported
actual #204 vs paper #646 442 places worse
paper 0.7840 ±0.0070
210
MLP
0.8690 ±0.0074
433
S^2GC
actual #433 vs paper #433
0.8020 ±0.0002
actual #433 vs paper #433
paper 0.8020 ±0.0002
paper 0.8020 ±0.0002 Δ at pub 0.0030
434
SEP-N
0.8020 ±0.0080
This paper
494
g-U-Nets
0.7960 ±0.0020
This paper

TU Dortmund

#ModelAccuracy ↑Paper
1
MSH-GNN
0.9910 ±0.0030
2
ID-GNN+BEC
0.9830 ±0.0360
3
SupCosine
0.9830 ±0.0250
39
GIN
actual #39 vs paper #586 547 places worse
0.9330 ±0.0290
best reported
actual #39 vs paper #586 547 places worse
paper 0.8139 ±0.0153
paper 0.8139 ±0.0153 Δ at pub 0.1191
63
GCN
actual #63 vs paper #759 696 places worse
0.9220 ±0.0440
best reported
actual #63 vs paper #759 696 places worse
paper 0.6950 ±0.0178
paper 0.6950 ±0.0178 Δ at pub 0.1960 Δ today 0.2270
101
TopKPool
actual #101 vs paper #766 665 places worse
0.9130 ±0.0070
best reported
actual #101 vs paper #766 665 places worse
paper 0.6761 ±0.0336
paper 0.6761 ±0.0336 Δ at pub 0.1223 Δ today 0.2369
141
MINCUTPOOL
actual #141 vs paper #643 502 places worse
0.9060 ±0.0460
best reported
actual #141 vs paper #643 502 places worse
paper 0.7917 ±0.0164
paper 0.7917 ±0.0164 Δ today 0.1143
158
GraphSAGE
0.9040 ±0.0780
190
SortPool
actual #190 vs paper #751 561 places worse
0.9000 ±0.0224
best reported
actual #190 vs paper #751 561 places worse
paper 0.7194 ±0.0355
202
GMT
actual #202 vs paper #511 309 places worse
0.8344 ±0.0133
actual #202 vs paper #511 309 places worse
paper 0.8344 ±0.0133

Improvement within reported uncertainty; not highlighted.

paper 0.8344 ±0.0133 Δ at pub 0.0004 Δ today 0.0646
239
DiffPool
actual #239 vs paper #640 401 places worse
0.8940 ±0.0460
best reported
actual #239 vs paper #640 401 places worse
paper 0.7922 ±0.0102
paper 0.7922 ±0.0102 Δ at pub 0.0596 Δ today 0.1018
367
ASAP
actual #367 vs paper #667 300 places worse
0.8740 ±0.0570
best reported
actual #367 vs paper #667 300 places worse
paper 0.7783 ±0.0149
paper 0.7783 ±0.0149 Δ at pub 0.0234 Δ today 0.0957
403
MLP
0.8660 ±0.0495
437
SEP-G
0.8556 ±0.0109
This paper
593
Set2Set
actual #593 vs paper #759 166 places worse
0.8084 ±0.0067
best reported
actual #593 vs paper #759 166 places worse
paper 0.6989 ±0.0194
paper 0.6989 ±0.0194 Δ at pub 0.0651 Δ today 0.1095
635
StructPool
actual #635 vs paper #635
0.7950 ±0.0075
actual #635 vs paper #635
paper 0.7950 ±0.0075

Improvement within reported uncertainty; not highlighted.

paper 0.7950 ±0.0075 Δ at pub 0.0237
685
SAGPool(G)
0.7678 ±0.0212
This paper
#ModelAccuracy ↑Paper
1
WL-MLP
0.9954
2
GIN
0.9934
3
GCN
0.9727
131
GraphSAGE
0.8200 ±0.0100
226
GMT
actual #226 vs paper #381 155 places worse
0.7990 ±0.0040
best reported
actual #226 vs paper #381 155 places worse
paper 0.7635 ±0.0262

Difference within reported uncertainty; not counted as underperformance.

paper 0.7635 ±0.0262 Δ today 0.0355
284
StructPool
actual #284 vs paper #284
0.7864 ±0.0153
actual #284 vs paper #284
paper 0.7864 ±0.0153

Improvement within reported uncertainty; not highlighted.

paper 0.7864 ±0.0153 Δ at pub 0.0103
304
SEP-G
0.7835 ±0.0033
This paper
355
TopKPool
actual #355 vs paper #510 155 places worse
0.7706 ±0.0090
best reported
actual #355 vs paper #510 155 places worse
paper 0.6702 ±0.0225
paper 0.6702 ±0.0225 Δ at pub 0.1004
368
MINCUTPOOL
actual #368 vs paper #432 64 places worse
0.7680 ±0.0160
best reported
actual #368 vs paper #432 64 places worse
paper 0.7425 ±0.0086
paper 0.7425 ±0.0086 Δ at pub 0.0185 Δ today 0.0255
415
SortPool
actual #415 vs paper #440 25 places worse
0.7496 ±0.0134
best reported
actual #415 vs paper #440 25 places worse
paper 0.7382 ±0.0196

Difference within reported uncertainty; not counted as underperformance.

paper 0.7382 ±0.0196 Δ at pub 0.0017 Δ today 0.0114
436
SAGPool(G)
0.7418 ±0.0120
This paper
463
Set2Set
actual #463 vs paper #503 40 places worse
0.7170 ±0.0073
best reported
actual #463 vs paper #503 40 places worse
paper 0.6855 ±0.0192
paper 0.6855 ±0.0192 Δ at pub 0.0295 Δ today 0.0315
#ModelAccuracy ↑Paper
1
MSH-GNN
0.9410 ±0.0330
2
GRDL
0.8260 ±0.0120
3
GMN
0.8225
7
DiffPool
actual #7 vs paper #363 356 places worse
0.8161 ±0.0232
best reported
actual #7 vs paper #363 356 places worse
paper 0.7303 ±0.0100
best at pub: Memory-Based Graph Networks (ICLR 2020)
paper 0.7303 ±0.0100 Δ at pub 0.0322 Δ today 0.0858
29
ASAP
actual #29 vs paper #320 291 places worse
0.7892 ±0.0145
best reported
actual #29 vs paper #320 291 places worse
paper 0.7392 ±0.0063
paper 0.7392 ±0.0063 Δ at pub 0.0500
31
StructPool
actual #31 vs paper #231 200 places worse
0.7884 ±0.0170
best reported
actual #31 vs paper #231 200 places worse
paper 0.7516 ±0.0086
paper 0.7516 ±0.0086 Δ at pub 0.0368
32
GIN
actual #32 vs paper #429 397 places worse
0.7880 ±0.0410
best reported
actual #32 vs paper #429 397 places worse
paper 0.7146 ±0.0166
58
TopKPool
actual #58 vs paper #453 395 places worse
0.7768
best reported
actual #58 vs paper #453 395 places worse
paper 0.7048 ±0.0101
best at pub: Memory-Based Graph Networks (ICLR 2020)
paper 0.7048 ±0.0101 Δ at pub 0.0720
67
SAGE
0.7726 ±0.0228
114
SEP-G
0.7642 ±0.0039
This paper
148
GCN
actual #148 vs paper #354 206 places worse
0.7600 ±0.0320
best reported
actual #148 vs paper #354 206 places worse
paper 0.7324 ±0.0073

Difference within reported uncertainty; not counted as underperformance.

paper 0.7324 ±0.0073 Δ at pub 0.0256 Δ today 0.0276
149
MLP
0.7600 ±0.0320
152
SortPool
actual #152 vs paper #356 204 places worse
0.7598 ±0.0176
best reported
actual #152 vs paper #356 204 places worse
paper 0.7317 ±0.0088
best at pub: Memory-Based Graph Networks (ICLR 2020)
paper 0.7317 ±0.0088 Δ at pub 0.0237 Δ today 0.0281
172
MINCUTPOOL
actual #172 vs paper #275 103 places worse
0.7575 ±0.0380
best reported
actual #172 vs paper #275 103 places worse
paper 0.7472 ±0.0048

Difference within reported uncertainty; not counted as underperformance.

paper 0.7472 ±0.0048 Δ at pub 0.0103
236
GMT
actual #236 vs paper #239 3 places worse
0.7510 ±0.0060
best reported
actual #236 vs paper #239 3 places worse
paper 0.7509 ±0.0059

Difference within reported uncertainty; not counted as underperformance.

paper 0.7509 ±0.0059 Δ today 0.0001
301
Set2Set
actual #301 vs paper #354 53 places worse
0.7429
best reported
actual #301 vs paper #354 53 places worse
paper 0.7327 ±0.0085
best at pub: Memory-Based Graph Networks (ICLR 2020)

Difference within reported uncertainty; not counted as underperformance.

paper 0.7327 ±0.0085 Δ at pub 0.0102
408
SAGPool(G)
0.7202 ±0.0108
This paper
#ModelAccuracy ↑Paper
1
WL-MLP
0.9792
2
MSH-GNN
0.9640 ±0.0070
3
CoCN
0.8722 ±0.0013
23
GCN
actual #23 vs paper #101 78 places worse
0.8260 ±0.0220
best reported
actual #23 vs paper #101 78 places worse
paper 0.8059 ±0.0027

Difference within reported uncertainty; not counted as underperformance.

paper 0.8059 ±0.0027 Δ at pub 0.0001 Δ today 0.0201
30
GIN
actual #30 vs paper #174 144 places worse
0.8220 ±0.0210
best reported
actual #30 vs paper #174 144 places worse
paper 0.7819 ±0.0063
33
DiffPool
actual #33 vs paper #165 132 places worse
0.8213 ±0.0043
best reported
actual #33 vs paper #165 132 places worse
paper 0.7868 ±0.0043
paper 0.7868 ±0.0043 Δ at pub 0.0059 Δ today 0.0345
57
TopKPool
actual #57 vs paper #191 134 places worse
0.8140 ±0.0094
best reported
actual #57 vs paper #191 134 places worse
paper 0.7758 ±0.0085
paper 0.7758 ±0.0085 Δ at pub 0.0382
70
SEP-G
0.8128 ±0.0015
This paper
86
MINCUTPOOL
actual #86 vs paper #88 2 places worse
0.8087 ±0.0034
actual #86 vs paper #88 2 places worse
paper 0.8087 ±0.0034
paper 0.8087 ±0.0034 Δ at pub 0.2287
93
GMT
0.8074 ±0.0054
This paper
125
SortPool
actual #125 vs paper #181 56 places worse
0.8007
best reported
actual #125 vs paper #181 56 places worse
paper 0.7787 ±0.0047
paper 0.7787 ±0.0047 Δ at pub 0.0220
136
GraphSAGE
0.7970 ±0.0170
142
Set2Set
actual #142 vs paper #144 2 places worse
0.7960 ±0.0230
best reported
actual #142 vs paper #144 2 places worse
paper 0.7955 ±0.0039

Difference within reported uncertainty; not counted as underperformance.

paper 0.7955 ±0.0039 Δ at pub 0.0005
151
MLP
0.7920 ±0.0240
164
SAGPool(G)
0.7885 ±0.0056
This paper
166
ASAP
0.7864 ±0.0050
This paper
200
StructPool
0.7727 ±0.0051
This paper
#ModelAccuracy ↑Paper
1
GC-GNN (GCN)
0.9210 ±0.0810
2
SUGAR
0.8403 ±0.0133
3
Ortho-g-U-Nets
0.8387
15
SAGE
0.8088 ±0.0233
18
DiffPool
actual #18 vs paper #88 70 places worse
0.8064
best reported
actual #18 vs paper #88 70 places worse
paper 0.7756 ±0.0041
best at pub: Graph U-Nets (2019)
best today: Orthogonal Graph Neural Networks (AAAI 2021)
paper 0.7756 ±0.0041 Δ at pub 0.0308 Δ today 0.0308
23
StructPool
actual #23 vs paper #61 38 places worse
0.8010 ±0.0177
best reported
actual #23 vs paper #61 38 places worse
paper 0.7845 ±0.0040

Difference within reported uncertainty; not counted as underperformance.

paper 0.7845 ±0.0040 Δ at pub 0.0165
32
ASAP
actual #32 vs paper #109 77 places worse
0.7950 ±0.0180
best reported
actual #32 vs paper #109 77 places worse
paper 0.7658 ±0.0104
paper 0.7658 ±0.0104 Δ at pub 0.0292
43
GCN
actual #43 vs paper #160 117 places worse
0.7912 ±0.0307
best reported
actual #43 vs paper #160 117 places worse
paper 0.7205 ±0.0055
best at pub: Hierarchical Graph Capsule Network (AAAI 2020)
paper 0.7205 ±0.0055 Δ at pub 0.0707
55
GMT
0.7872 ±0.0059
This paper
69
MINCUTPOOL
actual #69 vs paper #69
0.7822 ±0.0054
actual #69 vs paper #69
paper 0.7822 ±0.0054

Improvement within reported uncertainty; not highlighted.

paper 0.7822 ±0.0054 Δ at pub 0.0019
74
GIN
actual #74 vs paper #167 93 places worse
0.7805 ±0.0189
best reported
actual #74 vs paper #167 93 places worse
paper 0.7079 ±0.0117
paper 0.7079 ±0.0117 Δ at pub 0.0726
78
SoTA
0.7798 ±0.0057
This paper
90
SortPool
actual #90 vs paper #127 37 places worse
0.7558 ±0.0072
actual #90 vs paper #127 37 places worse
paper 0.7558 ±0.0072

Improvement within reported uncertainty; not highlighted.

paper 0.7558 ±0.0072 Δ at pub 0.0227 Δ today 0.0192
110
TopKPool
actual #110 vs paper #153 43 places worse
0.7640 ±0.0232
best reported
actual #110 vs paper #153 43 places worse
paper 0.7363 ±0.0055

Difference within reported uncertainty; not counted as underperformance.

paper 0.7363 ±0.0055 Δ at pub 0.0277
140
SAGPool(H)
0.7472 ±0.0149
This paper
146
Set2Set
actual #146 vs paper #161 15 places worse
0.7450
best reported
actual #146 vs paper #161 15 places worse
paper 0.7194 ±0.0056
paper 0.7194 ±0.0056 Δ at pub 0.0256
#ModelAccuracy ↑Paper
1
ID-GNN+BEC
0.8150 ±0.0240
2
GIN+BEC
0.8080 ±0.0330
3
GCN+BEC
0.7990 ±0.0340
4
GCN
actual #4 vs paper #75 71 places worse
0.7980 ±0.0230
best reported
actual #4 vs paper #75 71 places worse
paper 0.7326 ±0.0046
paper 0.7326 ±0.0046 Δ at pub 0.0074 Δ today 0.0654
14
GIN
actual #14 vs paper #92 78 places worse
0.7810 ±0.0350
best reported
actual #14 vs paper #92 78 places worse
paper 0.7278 ±0.0086
best at pub: Graph Homomorphism Convolution (ICML 2020)

Difference within reported uncertainty; not counted as underperformance.

paper 0.7278 ±0.0086 Δ at pub 0.0232 Δ today 0.0532
49
ASAP
actual #49 vs paper #88 39 places worse
0.7427 ±0.0397
best reported
actual #49 vs paper #88 39 places worse
paper 0.7281 ±0.0050

Difference within reported uncertainty; not counted as underperformance.

paper 0.7281 ±0.0050 Δ at pub 0.0146
55
SEP-G
0.7412 ±0.0056
This paper
70
GMT
0.7348 ±0.0076
This paper
78
DiffPool
actual #78 vs paper #78
0.7314 ±0.0070
actual #78 vs paper #78
paper 0.7314 ±0.0070

Improvement within reported uncertainty; not highlighted.

paper 0.7314 ±0.0070 Δ at pub 0.0128
85
Set2Set
0.7290 ±0.0075
This paper
94
MINCUTPOOL
actual #94 vs paper #94
0.7265 ±0.0075
actual #94 vs paper #94
paper 0.7265 ±0.0075

Improvement within reported uncertainty; not highlighted.

paper 0.7265 ±0.0075 Δ at pub 0.0188
95
SAGPool(H)
0.7255 ±0.0128
This paper
99
GraphSAGE
0.7230 ±0.0530
104
SortPool
actual #104 vs paper #104
0.7212 ±0.0112
actual #104 vs paper #104
paper 0.7212 ±0.0112

Improvement within reported uncertainty; not highlighted.

paper 0.7212 ±0.0112 Δ at pub 0.0092
108
StructPool
0.7206 ±0.0064
This paper
117
TopKPool
0.7158 ±0.0095
This paper
#ModelAccuracy ↑Paper
1
GraphSNN
0.7790 ±0.0360
2
SIN
0.7560 ±0.0320
3
CIN
0.7560 ±0.0370
5
GIN
actual #5 vs paper #90 85 places worse
0.7510 ±0.0510
best reported
actual #5 vs paper #90 85 places worse
paper 0.4813 ±0.0136
paper 0.4813 ±0.0136 Δ at pub 0.2697
38
GCN
actual #38 vs paper #53 15 places worse
0.5190
best reported
actual #38 vs paper #53 15 places worse
paper 0.5039 ±0.0041
paper 0.5039 ±0.0041 Δ at pub 0.0151 Δ today 0.0151
41
SEP-G
0.5153 ±0.0065
This paper
43
DiffPool
actual #43 vs paper #43
0.5131 ±0.0072
actual #43 vs paper #43
paper 0.5131 ±0.0072

Improvement within reported uncertainty; not highlighted.

paper 0.5131 ±0.0072 Δ at pub 0.0178
45
MINCUTPOOL
actual #45 vs paper #45
0.5104 ±0.0070
actual #45 vs paper #45
paper 0.5104 ±0.0070

Improvement within reported uncertainty; not highlighted.

paper 0.5104 ±0.0070 Δ at pub 0.0204
46
GraphSAGE
0.5090
48
ASAP
actual #48 vs paper #48
0.5078 ±0.0075
actual #48 vs paper #48
paper 0.5078 ±0.0075

Improvement within reported uncertainty; not highlighted.

paper 0.5078 ±0.0075 Δ at pub 0.0065
50
GMT
0.5066 ±0.0082
This paper
55
SAGPool(H)
0.5023 ±0.0044
This paper
56
StructPool
0.5023 ±0.0053
This paper
57
Set2Set
0.5019 ±0.0039
This paper
85
TopKPool
0.4859 ±0.0072
This paper
90
SortPool
0.4818 ±0.0083
This paper
SOTA performance (not significantly different from the best) Proposed method (this paper) Baseline / comparison (this paper) Global context (other papers) Best at pub — reported result worse than the best known when published (best reported in green) Best at pub — reported value improved over the best known when published Improved at pub — later paper surpassed this result Best today — OK at publication; today's leaderboard best is elsewhere