AAAI 2023

Union Subgraph Neural Networks

Jiaxing Xu, Aihu Zhang, Qingtian Bian, Vijay Prakash Dwivedi, Yiping Ke

Main figure for Union Subgraph Neural Networks

Abstract

Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) are widely used for graph representation learning in many application domains. The expressiveness of vanilla GNNs is upper-bounded by 1-dimensional Weisfeiler-Leman (1-WL) test as they operate on rooted subtrees through iterative message passing. In this paper, we empower GNNs by injecting neighbor-connectivity information extracted from a new type of substructure. We first investigate different kinds of connectivities existing in a local neighborhood and identify a substructure called union subgraph, which is able to capture the complete picture of the 1-hop neighborhood of an edge. We then design a shortest-path-based substructure descriptor that possesses three nice properties and can effectively encode the high-order connectivities in union subgraphs. By infusing the encoded neighbor connectivities, we propose a novel model, namely Union Subgraph Neural Network (UnionSNN), which is proven to be strictly more powerful than 1-WL in distinguishing non-isomorphic graphs. Additionally, the local encoding from union subgraphs can also be injected into arbitrary message-passing neural networks (MPNNs) and Transformer-based models as a plugin. Extensive experiments on benchmarks of both graph-level and node-level tasks demonstrate that UnionSNN outperforms state-of-the-art baseline models, with competitive computational efficiency. The injection of our local encoding to existing models is able to boost the performance by up to 11.09\

Proposed method: UnionSNN

Benchmark Results

Tested on 11 datasets 27 baseline values reported too low Non-standard metric on 1 dataset

Tables show presented results in global context (best 3 papers + GCN + MLP).

Classic

#ModelAccuracy ↑Paper
1
GraphSAGE+CNA
0.9418 ±0.0033
2
GCN+CNA
0.9366 ±0.0048
3
TransformerConv
0.9350 ±0.0058
21
GCN
actual #21 vs paper #798 777 places worse
0.9004
best reported
actual #21 vs paper #798 777 places worse
paper 0.7256 ±0.0441
paper 0.7256 ±0.0441 Δ at pub 0.1461 Δ today 0.1748
39
SAGE
0.8911 ±0.0012
44
GAT
actual #44 vs paper #776 732 places worse
0.8897 ±0.0014
best reported
actual #44 vs paper #776 732 places worse
paper 0.7482 ±0.0195
paper 0.7482 ±0.0195 Δ at pub 0.1408 Δ today 0.1415
141
GraphSAGE
actual #141 vs paper #816 675 places worse
0.8708 ±0.0085
best reported
actual #141 vs paper #816 675 places worse
paper 0.7060 ±0.0064
165
GIN
actual #165 vs paper #760 595 places worse
0.8660 ±0.0091
best reported
actual #165 vs paper #760 595 places worse
paper 0.7586 ±0.0109
paper 0.7586 ±0.0109 Δ at pub 0.0594 Δ today 0.1074
316
GraphSNN
actual #316 vs paper #767 451 places worse
0.8380 ±0.0120
best reported
actual #316 vs paper #767 451 places worse
paper 0.7544 ±0.0073
paper 0.7544 ±0.0073 Δ today 0.0836
458
CurvGN
actual #458 vs paper #787 329 places worse
0.8260 ±0.0060
best reported
actual #458 vs paper #787 329 places worse
paper 0.7406 ±0.0154
724
MLP
0.7768
741
UnionSNN
0.7686 ±0.0158
This paper
760
UnionGIN
0.7590 ±0.0080
This paper
766
UnionGraphSNN
0.7558 ±0.0049
This paper
782
UnionGCN
0.7448 ±0.0042
This paper
808
GeniePath
0.7216 ±0.0269
This paper
#ModelAccuracy ↑Paper
1
CNA
0.9575 ±0.0058
2
IS-GIB
0.9390 ±0.0187
3
EERM
0.9112 ±0.0145
35
GAT
actual #35 vs paper #796 761 places worse
0.8080 ±0.0026
best reported
actual #35 vs paper #796 761 places worse
paper 0.6382 ±0.0281
paper 0.6382 ±0.0281 Δ at pub 0.1698
44
GCN
actual #44 vs paper #840 796 places worse
0.8033 ±0.0088
best reported
actual #44 vs paper #840 796 places worse
paper 0.5830 ±0.0632
paper 0.5830 ±0.0632 Δ at pub 0.2113 Δ today 0.2203
61
GraphSAGE
actual #61 vs paper #854 793 places worse
0.7923 ±0.0053
best reported
actual #61 vs paper #854 793 places worse
paper 0.5502 ±0.0340
paper 0.5502 ±0.0340 Δ at pub 0.2421
259
SAGE
0.7361 ±0.0190
275
GraphSNN
actual #275 vs paper #783 508 places worse
0.7350 ±0.0160
best reported
actual #275 vs paper #783 508 places worse
paper 0.6468 ±0.0272
paper 0.6468 ±0.0272 Δ today 0.0882
350
MLP
0.7289 ±0.0010
389
GIN
actual #389 vs paper #805 416 places worse
0.7250 ±0.0080
best reported
actual #389 vs paper #805 416 places worse
paper 0.6310 ±0.0224
paper 0.6310 ±0.0224 Δ at pub 0.0940
506
CurvGN
actual #506 vs paper #815 309 places worse
0.7150 ±0.0080
best reported
actual #506 vs paper #815 309 places worse
paper 0.6208 ±0.0085
769
UnionGraphSNN
0.6522 ±0.0112
This paper
772
UnionSNN
0.6502 ±0.0102
This paper
798
UnionGIN
0.6366 ±0.0175
This paper
836
UnionGCN
0.5902 ±0.0364
This paper
847
GeniePath
0.5740 ±0.0216
This paper
#ModelAccuracy ↑Paper
1
LGTL
0.9518 ±0.0011
2
MixHop (LO)
0.9513 ±0.0038
3
GraphSAGE (LO)
0.9511 ±0.0036
18
GCN
actual #18 vs paper #806 788 places worse
0.9296 ±0.0015
best reported
actual #18 vs paper #806 788 places worse
paper 0.7444 ±0.0071
20
GAT
actual #20 vs paper #810 790 places worse
0.9233 ±0.0018
best reported
actual #20 vs paper #810 790 places worse
paper 0.7402 ±0.0111
116
SAGE
0.8881 ±0.0015
125
GraphSAGE
actual #125 vs paper #835 710 places worse
0.8864 ±0.0030
best reported
actual #125 vs paper #835 710 places worse
paper 0.7036 ±0.0429
paper 0.7036 ±0.0429 Δ at pub 0.1729 Δ today 0.1828
157
GIN
actual #157 vs paper #753 596 places worse
0.8810
best reported
actual #157 vs paper #753 596 places worse
paper 0.7662 ±0.0064
paper 0.7662 ±0.0064 Δ at pub 0.0414 Δ today 0.1148
210
MLP
0.8690 ±0.0074
489
GraphSNN
actual #489 vs paper #748 259 places worse
0.7960 ±0.0140
best reported
actual #489 vs paper #748 259 places worse
paper 0.7676 ±0.0054
paper 0.7676 ±0.0054 Δ today 0.0284
616
CurvGN
actual #616 vs paper #805 189 places worse
0.7880 ±0.0060
best reported
actual #616 vs paper #805 189 places worse
paper 0.7454 ±0.0161
635
GeniePath
actual #635 vs paper #832 197 places worse
0.7850
best reported
actual #635 vs paper #832 197 places worse
paper 0.7096 ±0.0206
paper 0.7096 ±0.0206 Δ at pub 0.0754
738
UnionSNN
0.7706 ±0.0107
This paper
742
UnionGraphSNN
0.7692 ±0.0056
This paper
748
UnionGIN
0.7678 ±0.0102
This paper
801
UnionGCN
0.7482 ±0.0110
This paper
#ModelAccuracy ↑Paper
1
GraphTARIF
0.9703 ±0.0019
2
GAT
actual #2 vs paper #351 349 places worse
0.9669 ±0.0014
best reported
actual #2 vs paper #351 349 places worse
paper 0.9186 ±0.0047
3
GAT+T
0.9660 ±0.0007
7
SAGE
0.9643 ±0.0027
8
GCN
actual #8 vs paper #361 353 places worse
0.9632 ±0.0008
best reported
actual #8 vs paper #361 353 places worse
paper 0.9171 ±0.0055
56
GraphSAGE
actual #56 vs paper #472 416 places worse
0.9508 ±0.0026
best reported
actual #56 vs paper #472 416 places worse
paper 0.8916 ±0.0103
best at pub: Elastic Graph Neural Networks (ICML 2021)
paper 0.8916 ±0.0103 Δ at pub 0.0174 Δ today 0.0592
226
UnionSNN
0.9292 ±0.0038
This paper
280
CurvGN
0.9250 ±0.0050
This paper
308
UnionGCN
0.9233 ±0.0053
This paper
314
UnionGIN
0.9228 ±0.0019
This paper
328
GIN
actual #328 vs paper #328
0.9211 ±0.0032
actual #328 vs paper #328
paper 0.9211 ±0.0032
paper 0.9211 ±0.0032 Δ at pub 0.0121
390
MLP
0.9128 ±0.0063
407
GraphSNN
0.9082 ±0.0030
This paper
422
UnionGraphSNN
0.9060 ±0.0058
This paper
450
GeniePath
0.8998 ±0.0114
This paper
#ModelAccuracy ↑Paper
1
GraphTARIF
0.9461 ±0.0017
2
GCN
actual #2 vs paper #321 319 places worse
0.9412 ±0.0008
best reported
actual #2 vs paper #321 319 places worse
paper 0.8458 ±0.0302
paper 0.8458 ±0.0302 Δ at pub 0.0327 Δ today 0.0954
3
GAT
actual #3 vs paper #291 288 places worse
0.9398 ±0.0022
best reported
actual #3 vs paper #291 288 places worse
paper 0.8594 ±0.0235
8
SAGE
0.9351 ±0.0006
46
GraphSAGE
actual #46 vs paper #428 382 places worse
0.9120 ±0.0029
best reported
actual #46 vs paper #428 382 places worse
paper 0.8030 ±0.0130
best at pub: Elastic Graph Neural Networks (ICML 2021)
paper 0.8030 ±0.0130 Δ at pub 0.0040 Δ today 0.1090
167
UnionGCN
0.8884 ±0.0027
This paper
222
UnionSNN
0.8776 ±0.0036
This paper
260
UnionGIN
0.8681 ±0.0212
This paper
277
CurvGN
0.8630 ±0.0070
This paper
282
GIN
actual #282 vs paper #282
0.8626 ±0.0056
actual #282 vs paper #282
paper 0.8626 ±0.0056
paper 0.8626 ±0.0056 Δ at pub 0.2146
320
MLP
0.8463
322
UnionGraphSNN
0.8458 ±0.0046
This paper
345
GraphSNN
0.8411 ±0.0057
This paper
388
GeniePath
0.8268 ±0.0045
This paper

TU Dortmund

#ModelAccuracy ↑Paper
1
MSH-GNN
0.9910 ±0.0030
2
ID-GNN+BEC
0.9830 ±0.0360
3
SupCosine
0.9830 ±0.0250
24
GraphSNN
actual #24 vs paper #483 459 places worse
0.9470 ±0.0190
best reported
actual #24 vs paper #483 459 places worse
paper 0.8404 ±0.0409
39
GIN
actual #39 vs paper #411 372 places worse
0.9330 ±0.0290
best reported
actual #39 vs paper #411 372 places worse
paper 0.8623 ±0.0817
paper 0.8623 ±0.0817 Δ at pub 0.0707
63
GCN
actual #63 vs paper #677 614 places worse
0.9220 ±0.0440
best reported
actual #63 vs paper #677 614 places worse
paper 0.7713 ±0.0524
paper 0.7713 ±0.0524 Δ at pub 0.1197 Δ today 0.1507
160
DropGIN
actual #160 vs paper #481 321 places worse
0.9040 ±0.0700
best reported
actual #160 vs paper #481 321 places worse
paper 0.8409 ±0.0842

Difference within reported uncertainty; not counted as underperformance.

paper 0.8409 ±0.0842 Δ today 0.0631
158
GraphSAGE
actual #158 vs paper #605 447 places worse
0.9040 ±0.0780
best reported
actual #158 vs paper #605 447 places worse
paper 0.8038 ±0.1098

Difference within reported uncertainty; not counted as underperformance.

paper 0.8038 ±0.1098 Δ at pub 0.1002
183
GAT
actual #183 vs paper #673 490 places worse
0.9010 ±0.0580
best reported
actual #183 vs paper #673 490 places worse
paper 0.7756 ±0.1049
paper 0.7756 ±0.1049 Δ at pub 0.1254 Δ today 0.1254
291
UnionGIN
0.8886 ±0.0433
This paper
318
GatedGCN-LSPE
0.8833 ±0.0388
This paper
371
UnionSNN
0.8731 ±0.0529
This paper
375
CurvGN
0.8725 ±0.0628
This paper
403
MLP
0.8660 ±0.0495
412
NestedGIN
0.8623 ±0.0882
This paper
456
MEWISPool
0.8473 ±0.0473
This paper
483
3WL-GNN
actual #483 vs paper #483
0.8406 ±0.0662
actual #483 vs paper #483
paper 0.8406 ±0.0662

Improvement within reported uncertainty; not highlighted.

paper 0.8406 ±0.0662 Δ at pub 0.0572
519
UnionGraphSAGE
0.8304 ±0.0870
This paper
573
UnionGCN
0.8187 ±0.0381
This paper
677
UnionGatedGCN
0.7714 ±0.0814
This paper
678
GatedGCN
0.7711 ±0.1005
This paper
703
UGformer
0.7566 ±0.0867
This paper
718
SAGE
0.7490 ±0.0870
#ModelAccuracy ↑Paper
1
WL-MLP
0.9954
2
GIN
actual #2 vs paper #118 116 places worse
0.9934
best reported
actual #2 vs paper #118 116 places worse
paper 0.8229 ±0.0177
paper 0.8229 ±0.0177 Δ at pub 0.1705
3
GCN
actual #3 vs paper #238 235 places worse
0.9727
best reported
actual #3 vs paper #238 235 places worse
paper 0.7973 ±0.0095
paper 0.7973 ±0.0095 Δ at pub 0.1754
4
GAT
actual #4 vs paper #317 313 places worse
0.9623
best reported
actual #4 vs paper #317 313 places worse
paper 0.7807 ±0.0194
paper 0.7807 ±0.0194 Δ at pub 0.1816
114
UnionSNN
0.8234 ±0.0193
This paper
119
UnionGIN
0.8229 ±0.0198
This paper
123
DropGIN
0.8219 ±0.0139
This paper
129
NestedGIN
0.8204 ±0.0223
This paper
131
GraphSAGE
actual #131 vs paper #534 403 places worse
0.8200 ±0.0100
best reported
actual #131 vs paper #534 403 places worse
paper 0.6394 ±0.0252
paper 0.6394 ±0.0252 Δ at pub 0.1806
181
UnionGatedGCN
0.8095 ±0.0211
This paper
185
GatedGCN-LSPE
0.8075 ±0.0167
This paper
202
UnionGCN
0.8041 ±0.0194
This paper
209
GatedGCN
0.8032 ±0.0207
This paper
253
3WL-GNN
actual #253 vs paper #303 50 places worse
0.7938 ±0.0173
best reported
actual #253 vs paper #303 50 places worse
paper 0.7839 ±0.0154

Difference within reported uncertainty; not counted as underperformance.

paper 0.7839 ±0.0154 Δ at pub 0.0099
255
CurvGN
0.7932 ±0.0165
This paper
434
MEWISPool
0.7421 ±0.0326
This paper
475
GraphSNN
0.7087 ±0.0278
This paper
493
UnionGraphSAGE
0.6936 ±0.0164
This paper
501
UGformer
0.6884 ±0.0154
This paper
#ModelAccuracy ↑Paper
1
MSH-GNN
0.9410 ±0.0330
2
GRDL
0.8260 ±0.0120
3
GMN
0.8225
32
GIN
actual #32 vs paper #372 340 places worse
0.7880 ±0.0410
best reported
actual #32 vs paper #372 340 places worse
paper 0.7286 ±0.0414

Difference within reported uncertainty; not counted as underperformance.

paper 0.7286 ±0.0414 Δ at pub 0.0414 Δ today 0.0594
39
GraphSNN
actual #39 vs paper #419 380 places worse
0.7842 ±0.0270
best reported
actual #39 vs paper #419 380 places worse
paper 0.7178 ±0.0411
49
GAT
actual #49 vs paper #296 247 places worse
0.7800 ±0.0300
best reported
actual #49 vs paper #296 247 places worse
paper 0.7434 ±0.0209

Difference within reported uncertainty; not counted as underperformance.

paper 0.7434 ±0.0209 Δ at pub 0.0366
50
3WL-GNN
actual #50 vs paper #509 459 places worse
0.7792 ±0.0209
best reported
actual #50 vs paper #509 459 places worse
paper 0.6018 ±0.0635
paper 0.6018 ±0.0635 Δ at pub 0.1774
67
SAGE
0.7726 ±0.0228
87
UnionGatedGCN
0.7691 ±0.0306
This paper
88
DropGIN
actual #88 vs paper #349 261 places worse
0.7690 ±0.0430
best reported
actual #88 vs paper #349 261 places worse
paper 0.7339 ±0.0490

Difference within reported uncertainty; not counted as underperformance.

paper 0.7339 ±0.0490 Δ today 0.0351
95
GatedGCN
actual #95 vs paper #140 45 places worse
0.7672 ±0.0311
best reported
actual #95 vs paper #140 45 places worse
paper 0.7618 ±0.0312
best at pub: GNNBenchmark (JMLR 2023)

Difference within reported uncertainty; not counted as underperformance.

paper 0.7618 ±0.0312 Δ at pub 0.0054
148
GCN
actual #148 vs paper #322 174 places worse
0.7600 ±0.0320
best reported
actual #148 vs paper #322 174 places worse
paper 0.7389 ±0.0285

Difference within reported uncertainty; not counted as underperformance.

paper 0.7389 ±0.0285 Δ at pub 0.0211 Δ today 0.0211
149
MLP
0.7600 ±0.0320
155
GraphSAGE
actual #155 vs paper #266 111 places worse
0.7590 ±0.0320
best reported
actual #155 vs paper #266 111 places worse
paper 0.7487 ±0.0338

Difference within reported uncertainty; not counted as underperformance.

paper 0.7487 ±0.0338 Δ at pub 0.0103 Δ today 0.0103
175
CurvGN
0.7573 ±0.0287
This paper
244
UnionSNN
0.7502 ±0.0250
This paper
243
UnionGCN
0.7502 ±0.0250
This paper
287
UnionGraphSAGE
0.7457 ±0.0235
This paper
319
GatedGCN-LSPE
0.7394 ±0.0272
This paper
356
UnionGIN
0.7322 ±0.0390
This paper
457
UGformer
0.7017 ±0.0542
This paper
464
MEWISPool
actual #464 vs paper #469 5 places worse
0.6940 ±0.0144
best reported
actual #464 vs paper #469 5 places worse
paper 0.6810 ±0.0397

Difference within reported uncertainty; not counted as underperformance.

paper 0.6810 ±0.0397 Δ today 0.0130
467
NestedGIN
0.6855 ±0.0322
This paper
#ModelAccuracy ↑Paper
1
GMN
0.7866
2
MemGNN
0.7550
3
TFGW SP
0.7510 ±0.0500
17
GatedGCN
actual #17 vs paper #35 18 places worse
0.7000 ±0.0494
best reported
actual #17 vs paper #35 18 places worse
paper 0.6683 ±0.0508
best at pub: GNNBenchmark (JMLR 2023)

Difference within reported uncertainty; not counted as underperformance.

paper 0.6683 ±0.0508 Δ at pub 0.0317
20
GAT
actual #20 vs paper #30 10 places worse
0.6850 ±0.0524
best reported
actual #20 vs paper #30 10 places worse
paper 0.6767 ±0.0374
best at pub: GNNBenchmark (JMLR 2023)

Difference within reported uncertainty; not counted as underperformance.

paper 0.6767 ±0.0374 Δ at pub 0.0083
25
UnionSNN
0.6817 ±0.0570
This paper
26
GraphSAGE
actual #26 vs paper #149 123 places worse
0.6817 ±0.0545
best reported
actual #26 vs paper #149 123 places worse
paper 0.5250 ±0.0569
best at pub: GNNBenchmark (JMLR 2023)
paper 0.5250 ±0.0569 Δ at pub 0.1567
28
UnionGatedGCN
0.6783 ±0.0687
This paper
29
UnionGIN
0.6783 ±0.0610
This paper
31
GraphSNN
0.6767 ±0.0374
This paper
32
GIN
actual #32 vs paper #42 10 places worse
0.6767 ±0.0583
best reported
actual #32 vs paper #42 10 places worse
paper 0.6583 ±0.0593
best at pub: GNNBenchmark (JMLR 2023)

Difference within reported uncertainty; not counted as underperformance.

paper 0.6583 ±0.0593 Δ at pub 0.0184
33
DropGIN
actual #33 vs paper #33
0.6750 ±0.0642
actual #33 vs paper #33
paper 0.6750 ±0.0642

Improvement within reported uncertainty; not highlighted.

paper 0.6750 ±0.0642 Δ at pub 0.0170
36
GCN
actual #36 vs paper #56 20 places worse
0.6650 ±0.0691
best reported
actual #36 vs paper #56 20 places worse
paper 0.6433 ±0.0583
best at pub: Hierarchical Graph Capsule Network (AAAI 2020)

Difference within reported uncertainty; not counted as underperformance.

paper 0.6433 ±0.0583 Δ at pub 0.0217
51
UnionGCN
0.6467 ±0.0714
This paper
52
UGformer
0.6457 ±0.0453
This paper
53
GatedGCN-LSPE
0.6450 ±0.0592
This paper
112
UnionGraphSAGE
0.5832 ±0.0264
This paper
122
CurvGN
0.5650 ±0.0713
This paper
124
MLP
0.5583 ±0.0352
126
SAGE
0.5550 ±0.0511
137
NestedGIN
0.5467 ±0.0999
This paper
138
3WL-GNN
0.5417 ±0.0625
This paper
142
MEWISPool
0.5366 ±0.0607
This paper

OGB

#ModelROC-AUC ↑Paper
1
Multi-RF Fusion with Multi-GNN Blending
0.8476 ±0.0002
2
HyperFusion
0.8475 ±0.0003
3
PAS+FPs
0.8420 ±0.0015
9
GatedGCN
0.8090 ±0.0160
80
GraphSNN
actual #80 vs paper #272 192 places worse
0.7851 ±0.0170
best reported
actual #80 vs paper #272 192 places worse
paper 0.7305 ±0.0040
109
GIN
actual #109 vs paper #286 177 places worse
0.7780 ±0.0182
best reported
actual #109 vs paper #286 177 places worse
paper 0.7060 ±0.0256
paper 0.7060 ±0.0256 Δ at pub 0.0720
140
GAT
actual #140 vs paper #286 146 places worse
0.7717 ±0.0137
best reported
actual #140 vs paper #286 146 places worse
paper 0.7060 ±0.0178
paper 0.7060 ±0.0178 Δ at pub 0.0657
160
GraphSAGE
actual #160 vs paper #288 128 places worse
0.7690 ±0.0136
best reported
actual #160 vs paper #288 128 places worse
paper 0.7037 ±0.0042
paper 0.7037 ±0.0042 Δ at pub 0.0653
184
GCN
actual #184 vs paper #265 81 places worse
0.7630 ±0.0030
best reported
actual #184 vs paper #265 81 places worse
paper 0.7349 ±0.0199
paper 0.7349 ±0.0199 Δ at pub 0.0281
249
UnionSNN
0.7444 ±0.0121
This paper
269
CurvGN
0.7317 ±0.0089
This paper

MoleculeNet

Tox21

Global leaderboard →
Non-default metric. This paper reports Accuracy; the dataset default is ROC-AUC. Values below use Accuracy only.

Sorted by Accuracy. Highlighted rows are from other papers.

#ModelAccuracy ↑Paper
1
GraphSNN
0.9224 ±0.0059
This paper
2
UnionSNN
0.9176 ±0.0085
This paper
3
GIN
0.9174 ±0.0095
This paper
4
UnionGIN
0.9174 ±0.0074
This paper
5
GatedGCN-LSPE
0.9171 ±0.0071
This paper
6
DropGIN
0.9166 ±0.0092
This paper
7
UnionGCN
0.9163 ±0.0072
This paper
8
NestedGIN
0.9142 ±0.0118
This paper
9
UnionGatedGCN
0.9131 ±0.0089
This paper
10
CurvGN
0.9087 ±0.0038
This paper
11
GatedGCN
0.9083 ±0.0096
This paper
12
GAT
0.9035 ±0.0071
This paper
13
3WL-GNN
0.9031 ±0.0133
This paper
14
GCN
actual #14 vs paper #14
0.9010 ±0.0077
actual #14 vs paper #14
paper 0.9010 ±0.0077
paper 0.9010 ±0.0077 Δ at pub 0.0610
15
UnionGraphSAGE
0.8859 ±0.0012
This paper
16
GraphSAGE
0.8836 ±0.0015
This paper
17
MEWISPool
0.8813 ±0.0005
This paper
18
UGformer
0.8806 ±0.0050
This paper
SOTA performance (not significantly different from the best) Proposed method (this paper) Baseline / comparison (this paper) Global context (other papers) Best at pub — reported result worse than the best known when published (best reported in green) Best at pub — reported value improved over the best known when published Best today — OK at publication; today's leaderboard best is elsewhere